Hooper,
i agree with TarponTom Royal Hawaiian Motel
is pretty good specially if you have your own boat but i would try
Cheeca Lodge ... this site has excellent guides that might be something to check
Guides... if i was to refer, it would be "Rick Murphy" as i heard this fellow is excellent... another helpful site
Islamorada Hooper for Bud & Mary's in Islamorada its a nice place specially women in thongs sometimes hard to keep your eyes straight ahead [img]images/icons/rolleyes.gif[/img]
Hope this is helpful