Well, where is the value point between these two boats that have been on BTOL recently, and how do they relate to the MA in question? If you accept the point that the prices reflect the desire of both sellers to get the max amount for their boats, can either of these 2 ads support the numbers that are being discussed in this thread?
1980 MA. with a 1988, 150 HP Evinrude:
http://adcache.boattraderonline.com/6/1/2/78345412.htm
Hull in average condition, engine tests to spec's, 3 soft spots in the deck, original wiring, gauges, fuel tank, etc. and no electronics fish finder, GPS, etc.).
In fairness, I should say that I was interested in 1980 MA advertised on BTOL, to the point that I had it surveyed and made an offer which was rejected.
1977 Fisherman with a 1999, 200 HP Yamaha.
http://adcache.boattraderonline.com/6/5/8/77826158.htm
2-3 weeks ago, Dixie Marine said the price on the 77' Fisherman was $9,500, take it or leave it; offres were not being accepted.
Different hull configuration, larger and much newer engine, new (5 years ago)tank (urethan coated), wiring and gauges, typical array of small boat electronics (VHF, GPS, etc.). Everything looks to be in very good condition (I have not actually seen this boat).