[ocuyler]

Tommy,

I agree with Capt. Chuck. I don't think this is the place to debate these hulls because it's a SC site and we're here for a reason.

I will, however, tell you from experience that the best boat is the one under you at the moment. They are both terrific boats and you'll be lucky to own either.

Like anything else you really love, you should buy the best and most boat for the budget you have. Not all of us can afford to renovate a SC 23 to it's fullest for 30 something But most of us can afford to get a quality hull under us and enjoy life.

Best of luck with your search and choice.