OK, Adam as long as you are marrying Eve and not another Adam..

If you are with Eve, the middle Keys are a great place to kick back and
relax..

If it is Adam, Key West all the way.. You will have lots of company!
The best places to eat and stay IMO are the middle keys and Islamorada!
As a matter of fact get with YeA 20sf, he just became the manager at
the Sands in Islamorada...
Hopefully you will bring your boat! Your buds will be able to tie the cans
to the trailer.
Key West makes a great day trip.
It all depends if you want adventure or laid back..
Congratulations on your up coming marriage!