What would you guys do?

[kwluis]

Update:
I just replaced the prop this morning with a 15 pitch Mirage. Trimmed out, I hit right around 5500 rpm and just over 37 knots. This was with me and just over 1/2 tank of gas. The low end and mid range RPMs seemed smoother...if that is anyway to explain it. The engine sounded a lot quiter and felt better...the prop just doesn't seem to grab as much on sharp turns as the other prop did...but that's ok.

This prop seems to be a better fit for what I was looking for. Thanks fol all of the suggestions!

Luis