First plug. 4th attempt. Need mold help please.

[fg1]

Skip the silicone! Clean it all off and start over with a mold release wax or PVA, but not both. Why 2 coats of tooling gel? One should be enough, you should have 24 mils, cured - that's about the thickness of 2 business cards. But if you have to have 2 coats, wait 5 hours between coats. And be absolutely certain you're using unwaxed gel coat. You shouldn't be having so much trouble.